The Best Eyebrow Mascara? Check Out My Ranking!


best brow mascara

Hi!

Do you already have a good eyebrow mascara in your makeup bag? I hope you do! But if you don’t, I’d be happy to help you with your choice – I’ve created a ranking of the best brow mascaras which allow you to achieve incredible makeup results. Feel like a brow professional in your own home – you deserve it!

It’s been a while since my last post, and I was wondering what else I can surprise you with. It occurred to me that I’ve already tested a lot of brow mascaras available on the beauty market, so this topic definitely needs a mention. 

Is it easy to find a good brow mascara? Of course not! Being well aware of this, I wanted you to be able to save the time and money you would have spent on useless eyebrow makeup cosmetics.

With my brow mascara ranking, you’re sure to find a product that works for your eyebrows, and you’ll quickly see that using brow mascara can be really fun and satisfying. 

I thought for a long time that mascara would only be suitable for my eyelashes, but I was very wrong. My eyebrows are finally perfectly tamed, have a perfect shape, and, in addition, seem thicker!

Eyebrow mascara – transparent or tinted? 

There are both transparent and tinted eyebrow mascaras available on the market. What are the differences and which option is worth reaching for?

Transparent eyebrow mascara, as the name suggests, does not change the color of your eyebrows. However, it can tame and style unruly brows. This is a universal mascara that can be used on all brow types regardless of color. 

WHAT IT DOES: tamed, lifted, and styled eyebrows.

Tinted eyebrow mascara, on the other hand, is an option for women who not only want to style and tame their brows but also make sure they are well-defined. Every eyebrow mascara on the beauty market comes in several shades from which you can choose the perfect one for yourself. It will work perfectly for filling in any gaps and giving brows a thicker look. It will make your eyebrows look more defined too. 

WHAT IT DOES: highlighs the natural eyebrow color, fills in the gaps, tames unruly brows, give them the desired shape and keeps them in place

It’s only up to you which solution you reach for. Both options can be useful for women who want to achieve a neat brow look they can enjoy all day long

Personally, I rather choose tinted eyebrow mascaras myself, as I’m keen on filling in the gaps and for a full brow effect. 

Now it’s time to look at the products I’ve tested – here’s my ranking of eyebrow mascaras!

5 best brow mascaras – which one works the best? [RANKING]

NANOBROW SHAPE MASCARA

With this thickening eyebrow mascara, you can achieve excellent makeup results. I currently use it every day and I don’t think that will change anytime soon. It allows me to highlight my brows perfectly without having to worry about their appearance later on. 

My eyebrows are thin by nature and I struggle with many sparse areas, so I need something really good to fill them in. With Nanobrow Shape Mascara, I can fill in the gaps effortlessly and get visually thicker arches so that they look nothing like they did before makeup What’s more, I can count on the effects lasting even 24 hours without any touch-ups.

I didn’t have the slightest problem choosing the right shade for myself, and I’m sure that you will also easily find the right color. Each of them looks very natural

After applying the brow mascara from Nanobrow, my eyebrows are always perfectly tamed, filled in, and visually thicker. This brow-styling product meets my requirements one hundred percent.

I think it will work on any eyebrow and skin types, even sensitive ones – the formula is light and gentle

You can find this eyebrow mascara at www.nanobrow.co.uk and in many beauty stores (I don’t know if exactly Sephora has this brow mascara on offer but I’m sure I’ve seen it somewhere). The price is most appropriate considering its performance

YVES SAINT LAURENT COUTURE BROW MASCARA

I bought the brow-shaping mascara from YVES SAINT LAURENT some time ago, hoping for spectacular eyebrow makeup results. It didn’t impress me as much as the Nanobrow Shape Mascara, but its performance is still good – it shapes, lifts, and tames my eyebrows nicely. This brow mascara brush allows you to reach even small hairs and is soft and pleasant to the touch. It is suitable for both thin eyebrows that need more definition and thick eyebrows that only need to be properly emphasized to enjoy perfect-looking arches. 

The shades of this eyebrow mascara blend well with the natural eyebrow color. I easily found the one that turned out to be just right.

This eyebrow-styling mascara does not wear off and does not leave a stiff finish. After applying it on my eyebrows, I noticed that they started to look healthier and gained a soft sheen. 

It doesn’t work very well in terms of increasing the volume so you shouldn’t get your hopes up that your eyebrows will start to look fuller. Still, I think you can fill in the gaps with it, even the slightly larger ones.

After a full day, my eyebrows looked similar to after applying the brow mascara from YVES SAINT LAURENT. 

You can find the product in many beauty stores like  Sephora (eyebrow mascaras don’t cost much, but look out for special offers and compare prices at different stores).

LORD&BERRY MUST HAVE TINTED MASCARA

Another product that fell into my hands and I’m happy with. The eyebrow mascara from LORD&BERRY comes with a refined brush that lets me quickly separate my brow hairs and does it with great precision. This brow makeup product features a good formula and contains thickening nylon fibers – you can count on a gentle brow lift and a thicker brow look.

I liked all the available shades but I have some reservations about the consistency of the product itself. It is sticky and it is easy to get brow hairs stuck together. Only after a few attempts, I could finally tell how much mascara I should apply on my eyebrows for a natural and not overdrawn effect.

It’s the kind of brow mascara you have to learn how to operate, but I think it’s worth it nonetheless. I don’t know if it will work on sensitive skin, but in my opinion, it is suitable for thin eyebrows that need extra definition

This eyebrow mascara is available in many beauty stores at an affordable price. 

BENEFIT GIMME BROW+ 

I bought this brow mascara because of the many positive reviews. I wanted to see if it actually thickens the brows and adds extra volume. The effect is a little worse than I expected – the thickening properties are subtle, almost imperceptible. Perhaps on thicker eyebrows that don’t have as many gaps the results would be much better. I’m not sure about it though. 

The consistency of the product itself is pretty good – after applying the product, the eyebrows seem more defined and not sticky. You also don’t have to worry about the mascara smudging or wearing off. 

The product lasts on my eyebrows for up to 10-12 hours without having to do any touch-ups.

You can find this eyebrow mascara in many online and regular beauty stores (Sephora, for example). 

KIKO MILANO EYEBROW FIBERS COLORED MASCARA

I think I liked this eyebrow mascara the least out of all the ones tested. However, that doesn’t mean it doesn’t have any advantages. What is certainly noteworthy is that it styles the brows quite well, giving them the desired shape. However, don’t expect it to fill in the gaps well or to deliver a thicker brow effect. The consistency of the product is flawless but the brush could be a bit better, as I have the impression that too much product settles on it and it is difficult to apply it evenly on the eyebrows. 

I know that this brow mascara is available in many beauty stores (I’m not sure about Rossmann, Douglas should have it on offer).

Eyebrow mascara – how to use it? 

Eyebrow mascara is a brow-styling product that is becoming increasingly popular among women. Undoubtedly, this is due to its easy application. It only takes a few brush strokes to apply the product. 

Once you have the best eyebrow mascara, all you have to do is to apply it properly. 

Here’s how to use brow mascara:

  1. Cleanse your brows with a face toner or micellar water.
  2. Start applying the mascara to your eyebrows with the brush. Apply the product evenly and thoroughly.
  3. Remember that there should be a little more mascara on the tail. 
  4. Wait for the eyebrow mascara to set.
  5. If necessary, apply another coat if you want extra definition.
  6. Done!

With good brow mascara, you will be able to give your eyebrows a whole new look without unwanted sparse areas – even if it seems impossible now!

Take advantage of my best brow mascara ranking and choose the product that suits your needs most. 

I’m sure it won’t be long before all of you will be satisfied with the appearance of your arches. 

Let me know which brow makeup products you like best! (I wonder if I have already tested it… or maybe it’s already in my makeup bag?).

Have a lovely day!